Personal Opinion · Dr. Sinnet Roy
An easy question to ask. An impossible question to answer honestly. Here is my take — and what you should be asking instead.
"Best plastic surgeon in Kochi." "Best cosmetic surgeon in Kerala." "Top plastic surgeon near me." People type this into Google every day. It is an easy question. The problem is — how do you measure it?
There is no comparison study between plastic surgeons. There is no randomised controlled trial on this topic. There is no impartial body that collects every surgical result, grades it, and publishes a ranking. It does not exist — not in Kochi, not in Kerala, not anywhere in India.
Whatever patients say and hear is based on hearsay. One person's experience. One opinion dressed up as fact.
"I can say Dr. Sinnet Roy is the best plastic surgeon in Kochi. But how will you confirm it? How will you refute it? You cannot. That is exactly the problem."
— Dr. Sinnet RoyYou can ask around. You might find someone ranked by "awards from XYZ." But awards are not outcome data. Awards do not tell you complication rates, patient satisfaction, or long-term results. None of this is reproducible evidence.
It is an absurd question. And you will not get the true right answer — unless there is a mechanism to report all results and someone to rank them impartially. That mechanism does not exist.
In India, "cosmetic surgeon" is not a recognised medical qualification. Anyone — a dentist, a dermatologist, a general practitioner — can call themselves a cosmetic surgeon and offer procedures. There is no law stopping them.
A plastic surgeon has completed a specific, regulated training: an MCh in Plastic Surgery or a DrNB in Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery — a three-year superspeciality programme after a Master's in General Surgery. It is verifiable through the Kerala Medical Council or the National Medical Commission.
In the rush to find the "best cosmetic surgeon in Ernakulam," don't end up at a quack's workshop. Make sure your plastic surgeon is actually a plastic surgeon.
Ask for the Kerala Medical Council registration number. Check if the qualification says MCh Plastic Surgery or DrNB Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. If it doesn't — they are not a plastic surgeon, regardless of what the signboard says.
1. Qualification. MCh Plastic Surgery or DrNB Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. Not a diploma. Not a weekend course. The superspeciality degree.
2. Experience. Years in practice. Number of procedures. A plastic surgeon at a major hospital in Kochi or Ernakulam — handling both cosmetic and reconstructive cases — will have breadth that a standalone clinic cannot offer.
3. Place of work. A surgeon in a well-equipped hospital — with an ICU, an anaesthesia team, emergency infrastructure — is a different proposition from an unregistered clinic.
4. Talk to the surgeon. The most underrated step. How does the surgeon listen? Do they explain risks? Do they promise unrealistic results? The consultation itself is the test.
5. Second opinion. If you are still in doubt — take a second opinion from another qualified plastic surgeon. That is not an insult. It is common sense.
The best plastic surgeon is not the one with the flashiest Instagram page or the most awards on a shelf. It is the one who tells you the truth — about what is possible, what is not, and what the risks are.
Stop looking for "the best." Start looking for someone qualified, experienced, and willing to have an honest conversation before picking up a scalpel. That is the only reliable filter that exists.
Personal opinion by Dr. Sinnet Roy, MCh Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeon, Lakeshore Hospital, Ernakulam, Kochi. Not clinical advice. If considering a procedure, a formal consultation is the first step.
Online and in-person consultations available across Kerala.
Book a Consultation