Personal Opinion · Dr. Sinnet Roy
And I mean that in ways most surgeons don't say out loud. Here is my honest view — unfiltered — on what makes this field uniquely difficult, and what every patient must understand before walking into an operation theatre.
Cosmetic surgery is not like other surgery. It operates in a completely different dimension — not just technically, but philosophically. The rules change. The measures of success change. And if you don't understand that going in, the outcome — no matter how technically correct — can leave both of us unhappy. Here is my honest view on why.
When a person comes to me for gynecomastia, rhinoplasty, or a tummy tuck — they are a normal, healthy person. There is no disease. No pathology threatening their life or their organ function. If they walk out of my consultation room and never see another surgeon in their life, nothing bad happens to them medically.
That is the biggest differentiating factor compared to every other surgical field. A cardiac surgeon is operating to keep someone alive. An orthopaedic surgeon is restoring function that's been lost. I am operating on someone who doesn't need surgery to survive or to function.
"They are coming to me to feel better about themselves. That is not a small thing. But it is a fundamentally different thing."
— Dr. Sinnet RoyThis shifts where the burden of justification lies. In most surgery: risk of surgery vs. risk of NOT operating. Here, the risk of not operating is zero. Every complication, every scar, every outcome that doesn't meet expectations carries more weight — because the alternative was perfectly fine. Understand clearly that you are choosing this from a position of health. The decision carries full responsibility — for both of us.
This is where cosmetic surgery becomes a double-edged sword. What I think is beautiful may not be what you think is beautiful. And even if our general sense of beauty overlaps — there will be nuances, small shifts in proportion, subtle details, that only you can feel and only you can appreciate. I might not even be able to see what you see. And yet that gap — between what you envisioned and what I delivered — can make an objectively perfect surgical result feel like a failure.
You may not achieve exactly what you strived for. Not because the surgery went wrong. Not because I made a mistake. But because the gap between an internal vision and a surgical result is genuinely hard to close. That is going to be a problem for you. And it is going to be a problem for me.
I have seen technically excellent outcomes that left patients dissatisfied. And imperfect outcomes that left patients overjoyed — because we were aligned on what mattered. The alignment before surgery often determines the outcome more than the surgery itself. This is why I spend time in consultation asking you to be specific: not "I want to look better," but what bothers you, exactly where, and what "better" looks like in your mind.
This is the Damocles sword above every surgeon's head. No surgeon, no anaesthetist, in any country, of any background, would ever intentionally cause a complication. When they occur — and they do, even in the best hands — it is because of things not fully in anyone's control. Anatomy that behaves unexpectedly. A healing response that doesn't follow the textbook.
If there were any way to prevent every complication, every surgeon on earth would do it without hesitation. We are not withholding safety. We are operating inside the limits of what medicine currently knows and what the human body allows.
You and I, together, can reduce the chance of complications to the smallest possible level. Not eliminate — reduce. Being medically optimised, disclosing your full history, following preoperative instructions, attending follow-ups — these are not bureaucratic boxes. They are the mechanisms through which we jointly manage risk. My part is honest candidate assessment, choosing the technique that suits your anatomy, and refusing to operate when conditions aren't right.
Here is the only approach I've found that leads to good outcomes — for patients and for me.
After full information — realistic outcomes, limitations, and complications — is your mind still itching? Is the desire still there even after hearing the full picture? If yes, then and only then should you proceed. Surgery taken to silence a doubt is different from surgery taken after honest reflection.
Whether you choose me or another surgeon. Whether your surgeon says this clearly or glosses over it. Whether you heed it or close your eyes to it — the issues are there. Ignoring the subjectivity of beauty doesn't make your expectations more achievable. Ignoring complications doesn't make them less likely. The only thing that changes when these things go unsaid is your ability to make a genuinely informed decision.
"Your body is a temple. You are a normal person. Take an informed decision — and do it only if your mind is still itching about it, even after hearing out everything."
— Dr. Sinnet RoyWhen the right person, with the right expectation, undergoes the right procedure — the results can be genuinely life-changing. Not because they look different to the world. But because they feel different to themselves.
That is worth pursuing. But it has to be pursued with open eyes, a clear head, and an honest conversation between you and whoever operates on you.
If that conversation hasn't happened yet — that's the first surgery to schedule.
This is a personal opinion piece by Dr. Sinnet Roy — not clinical advice for any specific individual. If you are considering a procedure, a formal consultation is the appropriate first step.
Online and in-person consultations available. No pressure, no glossy promises — just a direct clinical discussion about what is and isn't possible for you.
Book a ConsultationProcedures by Dr. Roy